Puzzles

Puzzles — Study Notes

Reasoning and Aptitude | MPESB Group 1/2/3

---

Overview

Puzzles form a time-consuming section in MPESB reasoning papers. They test your ability to organise scattered information, eliminate contradictions and arrive at a unique arrangement.

Three main puzzle types are: seating arrangements (linear or circular), scheduling puzzles (assigning days, months or time slots) and grouping puzzles (distributing people into teams or categories). Success depends less on speed-reading and more on disciplined notation—drawing the right diagram before reading conditions pays off heavily.

Students must develop a two-pass strategy: first, fix definite placements; second, test remaining possibilities. Most errors occur when candidates skip diagram-making or misread negatives like "does not sit adjacent to." Practising 3–4 puzzles daily for two weeks is usually enough to build exam-level fluency.

---

Key Concepts

• Linear arrangement: People or objects sit in a row facing one direction (single-row) or two directions (double-row). Positions are numbered left-to-right; "immediate left" means one position to the left.
• Circular arrangement: People sit around a table. Facing centre means neighbour on your left is clockwise; facing outward reverses this. Always mark direction arrows on your diagram.
• Scheduling puzzles: Assign entities to days (Monday–Sunday) or months. Treat the timeline like a linear row; conditions often use "before," "after," "gap of two days."
• Grouping / Distribution: Divide n persons into k groups. Use a grid where rows = groups and columns = slot numbers. Sometimes groups also have attributes (e.g., Team Red, Team Blue).
• Fixed vs Floating clues: A fixed clue locks a position ("A sits at end"); a floating clue shows relation ("B is two places from C"). Always process fixed clues first.
• Negative clues: "X is not adjacent to Y" eliminates possibilities rather than fixing them—note these separately and apply during testing.
• Unique solution principle: Exam puzzles have one valid arrangement. If you find two possible setups, re-check conditions; one will violate a clue.

---

Key Facts / Definitions

---

Worked Examples

Example 1 — Linear Seating (Single Row, 6 Persons)

Conditions:

1. Six friends P, Q, R, S, T, U sit in a row facing north.
2. P sits at the left end.
3. Q sits third to the right of P.
4. R sits immediately to the right of Q.
5. T does not sit adjacent to R.
6. S sits somewhere between P and Q.

Solution:

Step 1 – Draw six blanks: Position: 1 — 2 — 3 — 4 — 5 — 6

Step 2 – Apply fixed clue: P at left end → Position 1 = P

Step 3 – "Q sits third to the right of P" → Q at position 4.

Step 4 – "R immediately right of Q" → R at position 5.

Arrangement so far: 1-P, 2-?, 3-?, 4-Q, 5-R, 6-?

Step 5 – "S sits somewhere between P and Q" → S in position 2 or 3.

Step 6 – "T does not sit adjacent to R" → T cannot be at 4 (already Q) or 6. So T must be at 2 or 3; remaining seat goes to U.

Since S is between P and Q, test:

• If S at 2, then T can be at 3 (not adjacent to R) ✔, U at 6.
• If S at 3, then T at 2, U at 6 — T at 2 is not adjacent to R (position 5), acceptable ✔.

Both satisfy conditions so far, but check carefully: both work, yet the puzzle likely expects us to test upcoming questions; either branch is valid unless another clue differentiates. For typical exam format, if no extra clue distinguishes, questions will test common certainties (e.g., "Who sits at position 5?" Answer: R).

Final valid arrangements:

• 1-P, 2-S, 3-T, 4-Q, 5-R, 6-U
• 1-P, 2-T, 3-S, 4-Q, 5-R, 6-U

---

Example 2 — Circular Seating (8 Persons Facing Centre)

Conditions:

1. Eight persons A–H sit around a circular table facing the centre.
2. A sits third to the left of B.
3. C sits opposite A.
4. D is an immediate neighbour of both A and C.
5. E sits second to the right of B.

Solution:

Step 1 – Number seats 1–8 anticlockwise.

Step 2 – Place B arbitrarily at seat 1. "A sits third to the left of B" → Counting left (clockwise) 3 positions: seat 6 = A.

Step 3 – "C sits opposite A" → Opposite of seat 6 is seat 2 = C.

Step 4 – "D is immediate neighbour of both A and C." A's neighbours: seats 5 and 7. C's neighbours: seats 1 and 3. Common neighbour impossible directly; re-check wording—this implies D must be adjacent to A AND adjacent to C separately, meaning D sits between them along the circle sharing an edge with both. In an 8-seat circle that requires they be 2 seats apart—but A(6) and C(2) are 4 apart. Hence D cannot literally touch both; likely puzzle means D sits next to A at one seat and next to C at another seat—re-read: "immediate neighbour of both" typically signifies D is next to A and next to C. That is impossible unless exactly one seat separates A and C—here they are opposite (4 seats apart). Likely interpretation: D is adjacent to A, and separately D is also adjacent to C in a linear sense—conflict means recheck seating.

Alternative reading: D sits such that D is neighbour to A and D is neighbour to C (two different Ds? No). Re-examine: Since A at 6 and C at 2, if D is at seat 7, D neighbours A but not C. Perhaps original data expects flexible placement; exam questions sometimes have ambiguous wording tested via options. Key takeaway: always verify with given answer options.

For exam purposes: mark definite placements (B-1, A-6, C-2) and proceed; use E clue next. "E second to right of B (seat 1)" → seat 3 = E.

Partial arrangement: 1-B, 2-C, 3-E, 6-A. Fill D, F, G, H per remaining clues.

---

Example 3 — Scheduling (Days of a Week)

Conditions:

1. Seven friends attend a workshop on different days Monday to Sunday.
2. P attends on Wednesday.
3. Q attends two days after P.
4. R attends on the day immediately before Q.
5. S attends on Sunday.

Solution:

Days: Mon(1), Tue(2), Wed(3), Thu(4), Fri(5), Sat(6), Sun(7).

P = Wednesday (3). Q = two days after P = Friday (5). R = immediately before Q = Thursday (4). S = Sunday (7).

Remaining T, U, V for Mon, Tue, Sat — assign per additional clues or questions.

---

Common Mistakes

1. Confusing "left" in circular tables → In facing-centre circles, your left is clockwise. Draw arrows; don't rely on mental rotation.
2. Ignoring negative clues until the end → Negative clues ("not adjacent") are easy to forget. Write them in a separate list and verify each time you fix a seat.
3. Misinterpreting "third to the right" → Students sometimes count the starting person. Correct method: start counting from the next seat, not the person's own seat.
4. Forcing a single arrangement too early → If two configurations survive all clues, both are valid. Answer questions that remain constant across both or test options to eliminate.
5. Mixing "gap of 2" with "second to the right" → "Gap of 2" means two positions in between; "second to the right" means count 2 positions rightward (only one position in between).

---

Quick Reference

• Always draw the diagram before reading conditions—linear row, circle with direction arrows, or day grid.
• Process fixed/absolute clues first; floating/relative clues second; negative clues last.
• In circular facing-centre: left = clockwise, right = anticlockwise.
• "Immediately" = adjacent (no gap); "second to the right" = one seat gap; "gap of 2" = two seats gap.
• If multiple arrangements satisfy all clues, answer only what is common to all or test via options.
• Spend 4–5 minutes cracking the arrangement; the linked questions then take only 30 seconds each.